Perfection Fresh Admits Price Fixing: A $12 Million Penalty Proposal

Michael Corrigan, Emily Bunis
19 Nov 2026
6 minutes

Every week, suppliers of broccoli, cauliflower, and iceberg lettuce sent ALDI their prices. Perfection Fresh, Australia’s second-largest fresh vegetable supplier, has admitted that on 11 occasions in 2019 and 2020, it coordinated with competitors to fix its prices. The company has agreed with the ACCC to ask the Federal Court to impose a $12 million penalty.

While the other respondents have not made any admissions, Perfection's decision not to contest the ACCC case highlights a broader lesson that extends beyond fresh produce. Recurring pricing rounds can offer repeated opportunities for coordination with other suppliers, and result in multiple contraventions, each carrying its own maximum penalty. For conduct occurring after 28 March 2026, that maximum penalty is at least $100 million per contravention.

What has happened so far in the Perfection Fresh case?

In September 2025, the ACCC commenced Federal Court proceedings (ACCC v Veli Velisha Fresh Produce & Ors) against four fresh produce suppliers and three senior executives, alleging price fixing in the supply of fresh vegetables to ALDI.

Since we last examined the record $57.5 million cartel penalty upheld against BlueScope Steel and the ACCC’s newly filed ALDI proceedings, Perfection Fresh has become the first respondent to not contest the case.

The company admitted to fixing the prices of broccoli, cauliflower, and iceberg lettuce supplied to ALDI in New South Wales on 11 occasions between 2019 and 2020. At that time, the maximum penalty for price fixing was $10 million or 10% of turnover. The ACCC and Perfection Fresh will jointly propose a $12 million penalty, covering nine contraventions and one attempted contravention, along with an order requiring Perfection Fresh to continue its competition law compliance program. One admitted occasion falls outside the penalty period and will not be subject to a fine.

The claims against the remaining respondents are ongoing and have not yet been proven.

Understanding the penalties

Penalties for past conduct: the rules before 2022

Penalties are assessed under the law in force at the time of the conduct. For conduct before 9 November 2022, the maximum penalty for a company was the greater of:

  • $10 million;

  • three times the benefit obtained; or

  • 10% of annual turnover (if the benefit could not be determined).

For its ten contraventions, Perfection Fresh faced a theoretical ceiling of at least $100 million. The agreed $12 million penalty represents about 12% of that maximum.

How Perfection Fresh's penalty compares

At about $1.2 million per contravention, the agreed penalty aligns with recent court decisions for mid-sized businesses under the same $10 million regime:

Case
Conduct
Penalty
Key features

ACCC v Qteq Pty Ltd (Penalty) [2026] FCA 356

Five CEO-led attempts (2017-2019) to collude with competitors to allocate customers, structure bids, share markets, and avoid competition around a QGC tender for gauge works.

$5 million total ($1 million to $1.5 million per attempt), reduced from $6.5 million for totality.

ACCC sought $11-$13 million. Deliberate conduct to protect an $88 million contract. Executive chairman fined $1 million and barred from using insurance to pay it.

ACCC v Delta Building Automation Pty Ltd (No 2) [2024] FCA 580

Sole director offered competitor a bribe to rig a tender for the National Gallery of Australia (2019).

$1.5 million (company); $120,000 (director)

ACCC sought $2.5 million. Strong need for general deterrence (targeting a public institution). Three-year injunction on sharing tender information.

ACCC v NQCranes Pty Ltd [2022] FCA 1383

Distributorship agreement with competitor included customer allocation for crane servicing.

$1 million

Agreed penalty; isolated contravention. Three-year competition law compliance program ordered.

Perfection Fresh (proposed)

Price fixing with competitors for vegetables supplied to ALDI in NSW (nine contraventions and one attempt).

$12 million (about $1.2 million per contravention)

Agreed penalty subject to Court approval. Cooperated with the ACCC and made admissions. Existing compliance program to continue.

The higher aggregate penalty for Perfection Fresh reflects the greater number of contraventions. At the other end of the scale, BlueScope Steel was fined a record $57.5 million for attempted price fixing, reflecting its size and the senior, covert nature of its conduct. BlueScope and its former general manager attempted to induce eight Australian steel distributors and an overseas manufacturer to fix or raise prices for flat steel products. The Court found this conduct had the potential to harm customers significantly and deliver substantial gains to BlueScope. The penalty, approximately $6.4 million per attempt, was upheld by the Full Federal Court in August 2025.

Agreed penalties are not automatic

Agreed penalties are not automatically accepted. The Court must be satisfied that the proposed figure is appropriate and falls within the permissible range, with deterrence as a key consideration.

Judges compare agreed penalties against the statutory maximum and, for serious conduct, expect justification for penalties below the midpoint of the range. For Perfection Fresh, the $12 million penalty against a $100 million ceiling will likely be justified by its cooperation, admissions, and the limited scope of the conduct.

The fixed maximum has increased tenfold

The penalty landscape has changed significantly. For conduct on or after 9 November 2022, the fixed maximum rose to $50 million per contravention, and the turnover-based maximum increased to 30% of adjusted turnover during the breach period. On 28 March 2026, the fixed maximum doubled again to $100 million per contravention.

If Perfection Fresh’s ten contraventions had occurred today, the fixed-limb ceiling would be $1 billion instead of $100 million. While no penalties have yet been handed down under the March 2026 regime, future penalties are expected to exceed the $1 million to $1.5 million per contravention benchmark that has historically applied to mid-sized businesses.

Recurring pricing rounds: a compliance risk

The ACCC’s allegations focus on ALDI’s “agile” pricing category, where suppliers submit weekly quotes. Weekly tendering is common in fresh produce supply to major retailers like ALDI, Coles, and Woolworths, and there is nothing inherently problematic about buyers seeking regular competitive quotes.

However, recurring quote rounds can increase the risk of collusion. Frequent, predictable pricing rounds among a small group of suppliers create repeated opportunities for competitors to align their quotes instead of competing. When this happens repeatedly, each instance can constitute a separate contravention, quickly escalating the number of breaches - and penalties.

Fresh food remains a focus for the ACCC, which has identified enforcing cartel laws and protecting competition in fresh food supply as ongoing priorities.

The Bananas case

The risks of recurring pricing rounds are not unique to Australia. In Bananas (Case COMP/39.188, 2008), the European Commission fined Dole and Weichert €60.3 million for coordinating weekly banana quotation prices through “pre-pricing communications” held before prices were set each Thursday. While there was no formal agreement, the exchanges reduced uncertainty about competitors’ pricing, which was enough to breach competition laws.

The case highlights similar risks: perishable goods, a weekly pricing cycle, and contact before prices were set. These factors increase the likelihood of anti-competitive behaviour, emphasising the need for careful compliance in industries with similar dynamics.

Key takeaways

  1. Recurring pricing rounds carry risk: Each pricing round is a potential compliance event. Repeated informal discussions with competitors can lead to multiple contraventions, quickly escalating penalties.

  2. Penalties are increasing: While past conduct is penalised under older laws, breaches on or after 28 March 2026 face a fixed maximum of $100 million per contravention.

  3. Fresh food is a focus for regulators: The ACCC has prioritised enforcing cartel laws in fresh food supply. Businesses in this sector should ensure their compliance programs are up to date.

For more information on cartels or competition law compliance, contact Clayton Utz's competition law team.

Be the first to know

Legal updates and articles on the topics that matter to you, sent as they happen.

Subscribe
Disclaimer
Clayton Utz communications are intended to provide commentary and general information. They should not be relied upon as legal advice. Formal legal advice should be sought in particular transactions or on matters of interest arising from this communication. Persons listed may not be admitted in all States and Territories.